How doing everything right at work can still hold you back

Listen to Episode 78

I remember a moment in my career when I realized something didn’t add up.

I was doing everything I had been told to do. Taking initiative. Never saying ‘no’ to an opportunity (in fact, I was always asking for more). Speaking up. Showing leadership before I had the title.

 

And yet, I was still being overlooked.

Not in an obvious, dramatic way. I had incredible exposure in the coolest role.
But in the quantitative ways – like pay and promotions – and the subtle ways that are harder to name and easier to internalize.

The sense that I was somehow “a lot” in ways my male peers weren’t.

For a long time, I thought the answer was to adjust myself.
Morph my personality. Be more strategic. Say things differently.

 

But what if the issue wasn’t how I was showing up…
What if it was how ambition itself was being interpreted?

The punchline if you’re short on time …

  • The ambition penalty is not about performance gaps; it’s about how ambition is perceived and rewarded differently across identities.

  • Many high-performing women are doing the “right” things and still experiencing slower advancement due to systemic bias.

  • Workplace outcomes are often shaped by access, visibility, and assignment, not just effort or capability.

  • Career growth depends as much on environment fit and network access as it does on individual behavior.

  • Sustainable performance requires understanding when to adapt your strategy, and when to change your environment.

What is the ambition penalty?

The ambition penalty is the pattern where women are penalized for the same behaviors that are rewarded in men.

It shows up when speaking up is labeled as “too much,” when advocating for yourself is seen as difficult, or when confidence is interpreted as a lack of collaboration. It’s not about whether ambition exists, it’s about how it’s received.

And that difference in perception quietly shapes outcomes.

Why doing more doesn’t always lead to more

This is the part that can feel the most frustrating.

Because the narrative most of us were given is simple:
Work hard. Speak up. Advocate for yourself. You’ll be rewarded.

But what Stefanie O’Connell shares in this conversation is that many women are already doing those things and not seeing the same results.

The system just responds differently to women.

Research shows women also negotiate, ask, and lead.
Yet, they’re less likely to receive what they’re asking for.

Then at some point, continuing to double down on effort without questioning the system starts to create burnout.

How do you know if it’s you or the environment?

This is the question I wish more women were asking.

Because women are so conditioned to look inward first.

 

We think:

  • How do I say this better?

  • How do I show up differently?

  • How do I not come across the wrong way?

 

But a more powerful question are:

  • What kind of environment am I operating inside? Does it serve me, or am I only working in service of it?

  • Are people like me advancing here?

  • Are opportunities distributed equitably?

  • Is feedback consistent across peers?

 

One of the most important reframes from this conversation is this:

Your career strategy cannot be separated from your environment.

 

And one of the most practical shifts Stefanie offers is this idea: Always be looking.

Not from a place of dissatisfaction. There will be cons of every circumstance if you look for it. But keep your eyes open from a place of awareness.

Information creates leverage, and leverage changes how you show up and what your expectations of what’s acceptable are.

Why this isn’t just a workplace problem

One of the things I appreciated most about this conversation is how Stefanie expands this beyond corporate environments.

These patterns aren’t isolated to work.
They’re cultural.

They show up in how we define leadership, reward behavior, and interpret confidence, which generally depends on who it’s coming from.

 

Solving for this isn’t just about better policies, it’s also about awareness.

Otherwise, systems won’t change because individuals will keep adapting to them.
They also change when we start questioning what we’ve accepted as “normal.”

About the podcast episode

In this episode of The Life Management System, I sit down with Stefanie O’Connell, journalist and author of The Ambition Penalty, to unpack why high-performing women are often overlooked, even when they’re doing everything right.

We explore how ambition is perceived differently, how workplace systems reinforce those patterns, and what it actually looks like to navigate your career with more awareness and intention.

Related conversations you might find helpful

If this resonated, start here….

You don’t have to overhaul your career overnight, but you can start by paying attention to the signals around you.

Where are you being supported?
Where are you being stretched without being advanced?
Where are you being asked to adjust instead of being recognized?

There’s power in the clarity that comes with being able to see things more clearly.

If this conversation resonates, I’d invite you to listen to the full episode and let it challenge how you’ve been interpreting your own experience.

Key insights

  • Being overlooked is not always a performance issue; it is often a perception and system issue.

  • The same behavior can produce different outcomes depending on identity and environment.

  • Career growth is shaped by access, networks, and opportunity distribution, not just effort.

  • Awareness of your environment is a critical component of sustainable performance.

  • Systems don’t change when individuals over-adapt; they change when patterns are challenged.

I'm Courtney

I am the founder of Working Moms Movement. I’m also a wife and mom of two boys, a former culture and organizational change executive, an avid traveler, and a lover of sparkling wine.


I help working moms go from stretched thin and stuck in their to-do list to in control and fully present for what matters in their career, family, and wellbeing. Most of my work lives at the intersection of burnout, boundaries, and sustainable performance, because life shouldn’t require running on empty to hold it all together.


Let's stay connected!

Facebook
Instagram
Community

Start with clarity

TAKE THE BOUNDARY SELF-CHECK QUIZ

If something here feels familiar but you’re not sure what to do next, this is a simple place to begin. The Boundary Self-Check Quiz helps you see where your time, energy, and emotional bandwidth are quietly being stretched thin, often in ways you don’t even realize.

It’s designed to bring clarity, not add more to your plate.

Browse what's next...

Helping working moms go from stretched thin and stuck in their to-do list to in control and fully present for what matters in their career, family, and wellbeing.

Follow Along

Facebook
Instagram
Community